PHOTO CREDIT: Jill Fumanovksy
ORIGINALLY PUBLISHED BY TRIPLE J, MAY 2019
The Welsh rockers continue to be champions of the genre's longevity on third album The Balance.
Catfish and The Bottlemen are a band who know who they are. Over the course of three celebrated records, they’ve embraced an indie rock space that is defined by chugging guitars, anthemic lyricism, and Rockstar charm. They’re relatable to the point where all of their songs are singalongs, but they’re also powerful pedestalled performers - just far enough out of their audiences’ reach to make them an international rock commodity.
Sold out tours around the world, huge festival performances, and a fiercely loyal global fanbase have earmarked the band of bastions of modern indie rock, and they serve it up super well on album number three.
It’s a record heaped with hallmarks from a band who dare to double-down on what works, rather than throw away the playbook to write a narrative of reinvention. Which begs the question: when you know your formula and you love the music you're making, does a lack of wild experimentation matter?
On The Balance, Catfish and The Bottlemen prove that it doesn't.
The band exude athleticism and confidence, following on from sessions in the UK with producer Jacknife Lee (The Killers, Bloc Party, Two Door Cinema Club). You can hear a genuine love for these songs – whether they’re laying the riffs on thick, or moving through moments of introspection and vulnerability like on standout tracks '2All' and 'Longshot'. It’s already begun to translate to the band’s live shows:
"'Fluctuate', I love playing that song live," frontman Van McCann told triple j's Ben and Liam recently. "The singles, we like those songs, but the ones off the album that aren't necessarily singles, we're loving those."
The uplifting and optimistic nature of 'Longshot', as well as the grunge nuances present on 'Conversation' and 'Basically', are prime examples of Catfish and The Bottlemen's stylistic strengths. Not since the heyday of Kasabian and early-era Arctic Monkeys has there been a British rock band who has harnessed such palpable energy, teased on an album and full realised on the live stage.
"We've never had a one-off tune," McCann told Billboard in 2017. "When you come to a show you'll see that they [the audience] sing the whole album word for word, both albums now. I think we're at a place where we can properly appreciate it and grab it and run with it."
It’s true – in spite of criticism that the band “played it safe” on second record The Ride, the band have actually played it to significant success. “Running With It” appears to be part of the Catfish and The Bottlemen ethos, as the band have crafted bodies of work that thrive on consistency and coherence.
"The whole album, the artwork, the titles and the tracklisting; it's like the Rocky box set." McCann told Ben and Liam. "By the time Five and Six come out, you've got the full collection and you can all link up."
Keeping this in mind, it’s fair to ask what the larger Catfish and The Bottlemen picture look like. Following the Rocky analogy, perhaps there will come a time when reinvention will inject life and longevity to a proven and popular formula; but because The Balance does sound so alive and so current, it’s pretty clear that that time isn’t now.
They've aimed higher within the bounds of arena-primed indie rock on The Balance - 'Sidetrack' is sure to be set staple - without throwing in any alienating left hooks, or bolo punches.
As a matter of fact, taken as a statement album, The Balance sure feels like a defiant reply to the criticism that followed The Ride.
Catfish and The Bottlemen have reinforced their identity and struck a balance between the endearing songrwriting that first connected them with the pub crowds of their early days, and the huge, stadium sounds the band is fast becoming associated with and considering the norm.
The band has all the ingredients in place to produce rock music that will last, and when indie music takes its next turn back towards rock belter territory, Catfish and The Bottlemen are bound to be at the forefront with more new music to brandish.
"Simple things, get them right," McCann sings on album track 'Mission'. "You'll have enough to last your life."
Case in point.